Would/Could/Should- What Makes A Family?
By: Nina Roux
Most people reading this would agree that the definition of family has evolved, and we are willing to accept that families have two moms, two dads, one mom, one dad, no moms and dads, and families with adopted children, the list goes on. But what are the components of a family? Sure, love is one component, but there are plenty of families (like my mother’s) where that love is complicated and tainted by abuse.
I am the second-oldest of four kids, and my husband is an only child. Our respective childhoods were so dramatically different, that I think we bring a nice balance to each other’s lives. I poke him when he’s being self-centered and single-minded, and he prods me when I put everyone else’s needs before my own, and get resentful when there’s nothing left for me. We love the holidays – going from the chaos of visiting my family with kids running everywhere, and the dramas of accommodating thirteen schedules, to the quiet “us-centric” visits with his parents. Between these trips, we are always committed to giving ourselves a few days with just the two of us, so we can start our own traditions and just be.
I remember before we were married, we would sometimes spend the holidays apart. Then one day I decided that was crazy – just because we’re not married, doesn’t mean we should think separately when it comes to family visits. It was around this time that we also noticed that when one of us was invited to a wedding, the invitation would often say something like “unfortunately, we have to keep the numbers down, so no guests.” Beyond being tacky, I just thought this was the most disrespectful attitude towards non-married couples. I started to resent marriage, and saw it as some country club that only some were allowed to join (in many ways, it is), and it wasn’t until you joined that people would take you seriously as a couple. I was never a woman obsessed with marriage or weddings, I thought of it as something I might do someday, but hadn’t sorted out the whys or the whens.
We eventually did get married, more for our families than anything – and to us, it was important to exchange vows. Making a vow to each other, out loud, in front of 40 people we love and who love us enough to fly to the mountains in Colorado (the theme of our wedding, if there was one, was “meeting in the middle” since our friends and family are spread across the country) was meaningful and important to us.
But now, not having kids, it’s like there’s this other club we’ve yet to be indoctrinated into. This club is another one – as mentioned in previous posts – I’m dragging my feet a bit on joining. Not because I don’t want to, but because I need to sort myself out first.
But does that mean that the Mr. and I aren’t considered a family?
Is it kids that make a family?
That would mean that my friend who had her cancerous ovaries removed when she was 18, and who isn’t interested in adopting, will always be considered “childless.” As if there is something she is supposed to have but is lacking?
Is my best friend from childhood who has just never wanted kids, but who adores every kid she’s around, living a life that is “incomplete?”
Is the couple who wanted to have kids but couldn’t, and don’t adopt for other reasons, forced to be looked upon with pity like the single girl at the couple’s table?
Fortunately, we’ve moved on from calling single women “spinsters”, infertile women “barren,” and children conceived out of wedlock “bastards.” And happily, we’re moving into a time where more and more people accept that families are made of all different ethnicities, genders, faiths and views.
I do think it’s important to celebrate all the ways individuals define “family” – whether it’s 19 kids or none – because if we aren’t willing to say it’s an ever growing tent with wings, added-on rooms, fold-out beds, inflatable mattresses, sleeping bags on the floor, and a doormat out front that says “all welcome,” then that tent is bound to collapse.




